Afghanistan Sguardi e Analisi

Afghanistan Sguardi e Analisi

"
Afghanistan: Sguardi e analisi" è un progetto aperto finalizzato a comprendere e discutere le ragioni - e le possibili soluzioni - dei conflitti afghani.

Visualizzazione post con etichetta analysis. Mostra tutti i post
Visualizzazione post con etichetta analysis. Mostra tutti i post

venerdì 22 novembre 2013

I risultati della minaccia asimmetrica in Afghanistan

Gli attacchi suicidi: successo o fallimento?

disponibile in edicola

di Claudio Bertolotti 
 
Abstract
Dal 2001, il fenomeno degli attacchi suicidi in Afghanistan si è evoluto sui piani tecnico e militare imponendosi come minaccia in tutto il Paese. Esistono più tecniche classificabili come suicide - comprese le cosiddette green on blue (azioni condotte da soggetti appartenenti alle Afghan National Security Forces - ANSF); ai fini dello studio si è tenuto conto solo di quelle condotte con l’impiego di equipaggiamenti esplosivi IED (Improvised Explosive Devices).
L’argomento qui presentato è frutto di una ricerca analitica basata su fonti complementari: da un lato l’attività di studio sul campo durata circa due anni, dall’altro lato la raccolta e l’analisi delle informazioni open source e di quelle classificate rese disponibili attraverso l’Afghan War Diary (AWD) di Wikileaks.
L’approccio teorico adottato si basa sulla definizione di «attacco suicida» come azione offensiva, non-convenzionale e inserita in un contesto di guerra asimmetrica, che per propria natura prevede la morte consapevole del combattente-suicida e le cui conseguenze si ripercuotono a livello politico, strategico, operativo, tattico e psicologico.
Il combattente-suicida afghano - al di là di implicazioni ideologiche e culturali - quale contributo a livello strategico, operativo e tattico riesce a fornire? Sulla base dell’attività di ricerca, a seguito dell’analisi dei dati costituenti il database ASA (Afghanistan Suicide Attacks) creato dall’Autore relativo a 1.003 attacchi registrati dal 2001 al 2012, è stato possibile rispondere alla domanda portando un po’ di luce sull’evoluzione tecnica e sul ruolo dello “shahid” afghano.


THE RESULTS OF THE ASYMMETRIC THREAT IN AFGHANISTAN
Suicide attacks: failure or success?
 
Since 2001, the phenomenon of suicide attacks in Afghanistan has enhanced its technical and military plans, so becoming a threat throughout the country. There are many techniques that can be classified as suicide - including the so-called green on blue (actions carried out by individuals belonging to the Afghan National Security Forces - ANSF). For the purpose of this study, only those carried out with the use of Improvised Explosive Devices (IED) have been taken into account. The argument presented here is the result of an analytical research based on various sources: on the one hand, the activities of study on the field which lasted about two years and,on the other hand, the collection and analysis of both open source and classified information, which was made available through the Afghan War Diary (AWD), Wikileaks. The theoretical approach adopted is based on the definition of 'suicide attack' as an offensive and unconventional action placed in a context of asymmetric warfare, which by its nature involves the conscious death of the fighter and whose consequences have repercussions on the political, strategic, operational, tactical and psychological level. What contribution on the strategic, operational and tactical level is the Afghan suicide fighter - beyond ideological and cultural implications- able to
provide? On the basis of the research activity and of the analysis of the data which make up the Afghanistan Suicide Attacks database - created by the author and relevant to 1 003 attacks recorded from 2001 to 2012 - was it possible to find an answer to the question,shedding some light on the technical evolution and on the role of the Afghan “shahid”.

mercoledì 26 giugno 2013

GLOBAL OUTLOOK 2013. Afghanistan: A Prospective Analysis: 2013-2014 possible scenarios

di Claudio Bertolotti

GLOBAL OUTLOOK 2013 
CeMiSS - Military Centre for Strategic Studies
The full document is available online (Download the full document)

pages 40-46

Executive Summary

If compared with a ‘new civil war’ scenario (consequential to the dissolution of the Afghan State and the Afghan National Security Forces and the victory for the Armed Opposition Groups), events during 2012 tend to suggest a 2013-2014 scenario characterised by: an increase of local level conflicts; a political and social instability of the Afghan state and an ANSF unpreparedness – partially counterbalanced by NATO’s effort and support. The end result in the medium term is that Afghanistan will be kept in a condition ofunstable ‘dynamic stalemate’.

2013-2014 will be characterized by the implementation of the U.S.-Afghan Strategic Partnership Agreement which will guarantee the new formula of a U.S. military presence on the Afghan soil based on the medium-long term concession of strategic military bases.

The United States and the NATO, renouncing a real Afghan stabilisation, will proceed with the transition phase with a significant assistance and support to the ANSF (Afghan National Security Forces), at the moment unable to guarantee an effective control of the country.

The Taliban – formally and substantially undefeated – are military able, yet at the same time unable to defeat NATO-ISAF and ANSF troops on the battlefield.
Therefore, the Taliban will try to limit significantly the ANSF operational potential (and thus the effectiveness of transition) through the ‘trust-undermining’ process between NATO-ISAF advisors/trainers and mentored ANSF individuals.

A direct effect of this process is the increasing phenomenon of the ‘green on blue attacks’ (Afghan soldiers who attack their advisors and mentors), contributing to a further acceleration of the disengagement from the country.
Internally, political and electoral processes (characterized by limited transparency and evident frauds) will be influenced by the AOGs (Armed Opposition Groups) especially in rural and peripheral areas, in particular the Pashtun-dominated ones.

Observing the current situation, we cannot exclude attempts of political partition of the country based on the willingness to obtain access to the economical advantages deriving from the mineral and energy resources. This would create ‘fault line conflicts’, amplified by the limited governmental administrative capabilities and its high corruption level.

A positive role will be played by regional actors, which will increase their political and economical involvement.

In brief, in the next two years Afghanistan is going to be:
• relatively unstable from a domestic political perspective and exposed to the risk of a reduction of the role of the central government (advantaging local and peripheral powers),
• seriously precarious regarding its security and governance,
• inadequate vis-à-vis the transparency required by the international community’s economical support agreements due to an endemic corruption,
• surrounded by a dynamic and flexible environment regarding regional cooperation.